Đĩa 7" tại Mỹ/Canada/Châu Âu/Nhật Bản (1986)

1. "When I Think of You" – 3:56
2. "Pretty Boy" – 6:32

Đĩa 7" tại Vương quốc Anh (1986)

1. "When I Think of You" – 3:56
2. "Come Give Your Love to Me" – 5:03

Đĩa 12" tại Tây Ban Nha/Pháp/Đức (Dance remix) (1986)

1. "When I Think of You" (dance remix) – 6:12
2. "When I Think of You" (không lời) – 4:00
3. "When I Think of You" (beat mở rộng) – 2:00
4. "When I Think of You" (dub version) – 3:15

Đĩa 12" tại Mỹ/Canada/Philippines/Châu Úc (1986)

1. "When I Think of You" (dance remix) – 6:12
2. "When I Think of You" (không lời) – 4:00
3. "When I Think of You" (beat mở rộng) – 2:00
4. "When I Think of You" (dub / a cappella) – 3:15

Đĩa 12" tại Vương quốc Anh (1986)

1. "When I Think of You" (dance remix) – 6:25
2. "When I Think of You" (không lời / a cappella / beat mở rộng) – 9:17
3. "Come Give Your Love to Me" – 5:03

Đĩa CD tại Vương quốc Anh #1 / Đĩa 12" đôi quảng cáo – Deep Dish/Heller & Farley Mixes (1996)

1. "When I Think of You" (Deep Dish Chocolate City Mix) – 9:35
2. "When I Think of You" (Deep Dish Quiet Storm Dub) – 7:52
3. "When I Think of You" (Deep Dish Dished Out Bums) – 11:22
4. "When I Think of You" (Heller & Farley Project Mix) – 10:46
5. "When I Think of You" (Junior Trackhead Joint) – 7:08

Đĩa CD tại Vương quốc Anh #2 / Đĩa 12" đôi quảng cáo – The David Morales Remixes (1996)

1. "When I Think of You" (Morales Extended House Mix) – 7:43
2. "When I Think of You" (Morales Drum Mix) – 5:10
3. "When I Think of You" (Morales Jazzy Mix) – 10:19
4. "When I Think of You" (Morales Crazy Love Mix) – 8:45
5. "When I Think of You" (Morales Classic Club Mix) – 6:57
6. "When I Think of You" (Morales Incredible Boss Dub) – 7:12